The troll is nice but it's 0.2m wider. Bad news for me as as I only have a 2.1m space to squeeze it into.
The Eriba seats are quite narrow because of it's width, as the bed is also short, but Jo and I have lived in the Eriba through some quite foul weather, from 60mph beast from the east freezer zones last February through to the monsoons of last night and it is a lovely cosy little space to be in when the weather's howling.
The pop-top can be a little irritating, I still keep bumping my head, but in practice reduces the Erica to not much more the height of the Cali and does provide superb ventilation without the back of the neck being frozen stiff by an open widow.
Lack of an oven is no more of an inconvenience than it is in the California, we just use my little mobile one and with the end dinette plenty of space to put it on.I think that was the attraction to me. With minimum kit inside it can be tailored to individual use. It is almost a caravan equivalent of the Cali. I have a Triton, external length just 0.35m longer than the Cali, a couple of inches taller and all but an inch or so the same width.
It also packs a big payload. Anything you can't get in the Cali can be carried in the Caravan with relative comfort that you are not exceeding the MTPLM if you are sensible.
On the road it tows beautifully, but then 3 ton pulling one ton should not present too many problems anyway.
As mentioned above, there are alternatives. The Lunar aria is nice, I've had a couple of Lunar's in the past and been very happy with them, but so many British caravans are sold on the basis of the Bling you can see rather than the inbuilt strength that you cannot see, and the payload on the Lunar is fairly small. The Swift basecamp is intriguing but as with the Cali, I don't want to be fussing with awnings if I can help it.
As the end of the day, as with the Cali, it is such an individual choice if size and bling are not the first requirements. One has only to see how many 20, 30, 40 year old Eriba's there are and the price that they fetch to attest to the resale values if it's not quite what you want. As I said earlier, we had one for about six months, didn't quite like the dark interior, swapped it over for another and barely a hit on the wallet.