Anyone have Thule Carry All box? attachment to vw bike rack questions

[Canary Bird]

Hello! Does anyone have the Thule Carry All box? ... and attached to a VW bike rack?

I ask as I am considering the Carry All instead of the Thule Backup 900. I owned the 900 and liked it, but the Carry All claims to have 50-60 liters more and a warning sign can be permanently attached to it.

My questions if you own the Carry All:
? Do you have it attached to a VW bike rack? Attachment parts/pieces that you need?
? Do you need to drill holes?
? Is it a more permanent attachment or quick take off & put on bike rack?

Thanks for your help!

 

[zeratul]

Looking for the same thing. Any recommendation? Thule or Fiamma Ultra ?

 

[MattBW]

Out of interest, I saw some bike racks have deformed the body, is this likely with a box like this? I really like the look of it.

 

[andyinluton]

Looking for the same thing. Any recommendation? Thule or Fiamma Ultra ?

same thing different badge.

 

[zeratul]

Had a look at a thule backup 150, decided I won't use it. It's too large, can't see through rear window anymore, looks too ugly, car balance is worse (we're going offroad soon), parking is harder, and on top of that not easy to attach it on VW bike rack.
We'll stick to our 'travel light' principle, even with 5, and leave more stuff at home if necessary