I tried to make a balanced post there. I didn't say no they are horrible, I said They're definitely a good idea if you like that kind of site.
Personally I avoid sites whose rules run to more than an A4 page. Because I know that it's necessary to have SOME rules.
I'm often puzzled by the "rules" posts.
I'm as freewheeling as anyone but mostly in the past used their sites when I had been off grid for days and needed the facilities, wash me, clothes, dishes etc. In the last two years with a lot of caravan towing I have used both clubs extensively, just checking my diary 87 nights in Alfie alone.
I have had one knock on the door telling me the "Rules" state no cables joined together.
I have had one warden ask was I using two hook-ups on the one pitch, quite reasonable, any campsite owner would do that.
I have seen a warden ask someone to clean up their dog's mess and be thoroughly abused. I have seen wardens being abused because someone had kicked a football against their van and they were nowhere to be seen enforcing "the rules"...
On CAMC sites I have always been told place an offside corner to the peg wen pitching, no problem with that whatsoever as with everyone doing it it ensures maximum separation from my neighbour, an utterly laudable objective, otherwise it's park where you wish.
On CCC sites they select the pitch for me, as do most non-club sites, normally after asking me where do I want to go.
Otherwise, where are all these rules and "hitler wardens", as another poster called them?
Yes, me, on my own, prefer to be fancy free and either no neighbours or like last night in a pub car park with people to talk to after being on my own for a couple of days, However I have found neither club site "full of rules" or "hitler wardens" although there was one particular warden who was rather officious until he found me better versed in the rules than he was