So the decision is made, and the winner (for me) is...............
It was a really close decision and I would have been happy either way, but in the end I decided to stick with my Westy 'mini motorhome' (Shown here at Wastwater) AND the Skoda. The T5 Cali has gone to a new family today. A member here.
It was perhaps more the everyday driving experience rather than the camping experience that swung it. Although I got more familiar and comfortable driving the Cali in everyday use, it still felt very precious and vulnerable compared to a cheap workhorse Skoda. 'Everyday' use for me is lots of short shopping trips, muddy dog walks, frequently carrying unrestored antiques full of cobwebs etc.
Other influences, not in any particular order: (All shared with the new owner so no surprises...)
* I need business use insurance cover, and whilst this was obtainable, it did bump my price up considerably once I answered "no" to the 'do you have access to another vehicle?' question. Also, bumping up my annual mileage (to 16k vs the 8k / 8k on the car and Westy respectively) pushed up prices.
* the potential for roof rot and failing computer problems were a worry out of warranty. (That doesn't stop it being the best pop-top / rock n roll bed camper....but is a worry all the same vs my Westy).
* The T5 Cali was a better camping experience than I'd expected. The built in water tanks and picnic chairs / tables really free up space vs the competition. Reading in bed (downstairs), properly propped up against the tailgate was more comfortable than the Westy solutions. The drive was more relaxing vs the Westy, then throw in 174hp Auto......very comfortable.
* Although the Westy is only a foot or so longer than a Cali, the 'car dimensions' of the Cali made parking it in touristy resorts was a real benefit. I'll be back to parking on the outskirts and taking my assistant in on my bike..........
* I was blessed with nice weather during my trial. I think in poor weather, the space in the Westy may become more important.
* If I ever change my mind or circumstances change, finding a T5 Cali will be easier than finding another Westy Exclusive or Club Joker
* The lack of maintenance options outside of VW: I think a few independents with some specialist knowledge are starting to emerge, but generally it feels like you still have to rely on VW. As Granny Jenny has experienced, that can be painful under warranty, but imagine paying that yourself?
* Having a 'dedicated' camper means it can really be 'ready to go'. I even leave the bedding in during the season and literally only have to add milk.
So, there we go. Back to where we were. Thanks for following my thought process. I hope it proves useful to other members debating the same points. The obvious 'rider' is that this just represents my experience and circumstances, which are at best, 'not typical'!
